Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?

deviantART

 

Pixel Art vs. Pixel Shaded Dolls

Thu Jul 24, 2008, 5:29 PM
  • Mood: Frustrated
Although DA has made great strides toward improving the dolling community, and making us feel that we have a place here, sometimes it feels as though our *pixel shaders* are being forced to comply to rules and standards set by *real pixel artists* It is offensive to be told that you aren't complying to their standards when we are complying with the norm in the dolling community.

In our community, the addition of terms to a base laid pixel by pixel is a rather common practice. It is there (directly on the image) in a convenient place for any who use the base to see. It provides a reminder of the proper site to link back to when we show the doll and what editing of the base is allowed. It also avoids the complication of people who never read artist's terms of use located on separate pages (or in the case of DA the artist's comments). It also reduces the need for very detailed organization when one collects bases.

The addition of computer generated text (as long as it is not a part of the image composition) in no way determines the techniques used in the making of a base. A digital watermark added using a computer program on a water-color does not suddenly change its classification to a digital piece of artwork.

If our opinions on what constitute pixel art do not matter (because of disagreement with pixel artist and dollers with that classification) quite honestly, I think DA should simply change our categorization from Customization-Dolls- *Pixel Art* to Customization-Dolls-*Pixel Shaded*

If you don't know what i am talking about, go here and visit the journal of :iconzipple: or see the article written by :iconpyrochan-dolls: at [link]

I also urge our dolling community members to voice their opinions on this matter to our gallery director wrote about this rule in her last news article [link] It is quite the easy little note to miss unless you look for it!

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconpyrochan-dolls:
Totally irrelevant but I've just noticed I'm on your awesome people list over there ---------->
Wicked :D

And yeah I agree, we've been calling pixel dolls, pixel 'shaded' dolls for donkey's years, I don't think anyone has ever said ';pixel art dolls' I think that's more classified as a 'sprite' isn't it?

WTF is a 'sprite' anyway? I just think of the drinks can XD
:iconpackagedbliss:
Yes, a pixel art character is typically referred to as a sprite in classic pixel art terms in regards to like gaming. ^^ And honestly until DA, I never heard of a pixel art doll classification. It has for as long as I remember (and this is like...seven or eight years) been pixel shaded. I think putting our dolls under that classification was because until we got our own gallery people were uploading dolls under PixelArt>Characters.
:iconpyrochan-dolls:
I never put my dolls up in pixel art cos well.. they're not exactly pixel art XD
:iconpackagedbliss:
OH, yes, you are on my list of win...and that is wickedly old and needs to be updated, so feel doubly AWESOME that you made the original list. lmao
:iconpyrochan-dolls:
the Original list I am special!
:iconvanillaknight:
I put my dolls under pixel art characters and they moved them to the adopted base category and vise versa. It's ridiculous.

--
Spritle? Your name is Spritle? ಠ^ಠ
:iconheartsdesire-fantasy:
I disagree with that rule of the text as really the text has nothing to do with the base its just a way of putting your copywrite on it or sig..... I am confused any way LOL the saying adopted base doesnt sound right !

--
Av/sig base by [link]
:iconzipple:
Did you know... you're the reason I posted that journal? XD I had been debating when or if I was going to, but when I found the article through Glam... sigh. :/

Thanks for elaborating on the point much more eloquently than I could have. *high five*
:iconpyrochan-dolls:
Dolls should in actual fact belong in the dolls category, pixel art > Characters, is reserved for sprites and other pixel things.

We have a category now, let's make use of it.

Dolls > Pixel art > Adopted base, a doll made on a base not your own.

Dolls > Pixel art > Original base, if the base is your own.

Pixel Art > Characters, for sprites and other such characters which have been made entirely baseless, in other terms, baseless dolls.

Journal History

Polls

There are currently no active polls.

Press the +deviantWATCH button on this page to get notified about new polls!

ShoutBoard

My Sisters:
:iconsandi3d: :iconbeblue: :iconmilkbun:

Other Awesome People:
:iconabzdragon: :iconaceldama: :iconagaguck: :iconagent00ebil: :iconalithedairyqueen: :iconangelishi: :iconangychan: :iconasanosandwalker: :iconatacuivel: :iconautarkeia: :iconbeatricen::iconbitterkawaii: :iconbobxisxcool: :iconbombthemoon: :iconboywithmeese: :iconbubujane: :iconcherieosaurus: :iconcherry-blossom1228: :iconchocotini: :iconclandestiny: :iconelychan: :iconevilzipper: :iconfallensunrise: :iconfirstfear: :iconfool: :iconfoxyrepublic: :icongaladnilien: :icongoldenlove: :iconhanasu: :iconhazellyn: :iconiemme: :iconjakurinu-sama: :iconjethyn: :iconjishin: :iconjiuge: :iconladyoftherain: :iconlinaivelle: :iconlizbot: :iconlunar-eclipse: :iconlunie-chan: :iconmab87:
:iconmeganclare: :iconmeririm: :iconmistress-jaeden: :iconmokuren:
:iconmoonlightspectre: :iconoborochann: :iconpaxjah: :iconpyrochan-dolls: :iconredribbonstar: :iconriense: :iconsariyu: :iconscatron: :iconsego-chan:
:iconselfrighteoussuicide: :iconshadows-chan: :iconshirotsuki: :iconshonegold:
:iconshourimajo: :iconsissy20021: :iconsmitetheewithapples: :iconsugarcream: :iconsugareesweets: :iconsuhaylah: :iconthehword: :icontrinus: :iconutenasama:
:iconxaoxia: :iconzipple: :iconzoggles:

Shoutbox

*PackagedBliss:iconPackagedBliss:
I just saw all these marriage proposals. LOL. <3
Mon Jan 5, 2009, 9:15 PM
~VanillaKnight:iconVanillaKnight:
...I am? :noes: WHY DIDN'T ANYONE TELL ME?! Blast, I've promised to marry too many people!
Fri Jan 2, 2009, 1:24 PM
*Heartsdesire-fantasy:iconHeartsdesire-fantasy:
Bah your all gonna Marry me ;p
Wed Nov 19, 2008, 10:13 PM
~VanillaKnight:iconVanillaKnight:
Cheat on Pyrochan with me!
Sat Jul 26, 2008, 4:46 AM
^Pyrochan-dolls:iconPyrochan-dolls:
No Daria, she's going to marry me instead. Isn't that right darling?
Fri Jul 25, 2008, 3:42 AM
~petiteUlis:iconpetiteUlis:
All your dolls make me want to join EE
Tue Nov 13, 2007, 5:42 AM
*PackagedBliss:iconPackagedBliss:
*swoons*
Mon Nov 12, 2007, 8:37 PM
*milkbun:iconmilkbun:
marry me!
Mon Nov 12, 2007, 1:20 PM

ShoutBoard

My Sisters:
:iconsandi3d: :iconbeblue: :iconmilkbun:

Other Awesome People:
:iconabzdragon: :iconaceldama: :iconagaguck: :iconagent00ebil: :iconalithedairyqueen: :iconangelishi: :iconangychan: :iconasanosandwalker: :iconatacuivel: :iconautarkeia: :iconbeatricen::iconbitterkawaii: :iconbobxisxcool: :iconbombthemoon: :iconboywithmeese: :iconbubujane: :iconcherieosaurus: :iconcherry-blossom1228: :iconchocotini: :iconclandestiny: :iconelychan: :iconevilzipper: :iconfallensunrise: :iconfirstfear: :iconfool: :iconfoxyrepublic: :icongaladnilien: :icongoldenlove: :iconhanasu: :iconhazellyn: :iconiemme: :iconjakurinu-sama: :iconjethyn: :iconjishin: :iconjiuge: :iconladyoftherain: :iconlinaivelle: :iconlizbot: :iconlunar-eclipse: :iconlunie-chan: :iconmab87:
:iconmeganclare: :iconmeririm: :iconmistress-jaeden: :iconmokuren:
:iconmoonlightspectre: :iconoborochann: :iconpaxjah: :iconpyrochan-dolls: :iconredribbonstar: :iconriense: :iconsariyu: :iconscatron: :iconsego-chan:
:iconselfrighteoussuicide: :iconshadows-chan: :iconshirotsuki: :iconshonegold:
:iconshourimajo: :iconsissy20021: :iconsmitetheewithapples: :iconsugarcream: :iconsugareesweets: :iconsuhaylah: :iconthehword: :icontrinus: :iconutenasama:
:iconxaoxia: :iconzipple: :iconzoggles:

Site Map